Posts

Showing posts with the label comparative water policy

New Mexico, Bolivia, and customary water traditions

Image
A few days ago, I compared the interesting parallels (and differences) between New Mexico and the country of Spain. This time around, it's New Mexico and Bolivia ; here I want to create an opening for analyzing how both entities (again, a state, and a State respectively) have recognized local, customary water traditions. As you will see and appreciate, there are strong material parallels between how irrigators in Bolivia operate and how acequias in New Mexico handle water management and governance. The differences, however, are just as fascinating and have largely to do with how the claims to water are wrapped around cultural identity. My good colleague, Tom Perreault (Syracuse - Geography), wrote about the recent recognition in Bolivia of local "usos y costumbres" with special focus on the national irrigators' movement. Granted, that country has pursued an arguably anti-neoliberal path on water goverance in recent years, as Tom has suggested. But both Bolivia an...

Water in Spain and "New Spain"

Image
As I hinted a few days ago, there are some remarkable parallels between the historical geographies of water in the country (" S tate") of Spain and the s tate of New Mexico. I credit the information on Spain to a colleague in anthropology at McGill University (call him Ismael ; no, really). See back a couple of posts but Ismael's "Modernizing mountain water" appears in the co-edited volume Water, Place, and Equity (MIT Press, 2008)*, and is focused on the transformation of Pyrenean water use and its governance, largely on the Spanish side. I have put in a coarse table to outline the parallels between Spain's legal history on water and those of New Mexico. Table - NM by author, Spain from Vaccaro 2008 (230) TIME LINE                     New Mexico                        ...

Preview: New Mexico's 16th annual Water Dialogue

Image
As I get ready to attend the 16th annual statewide meeeting of the New Mexico Water Dialogue (sic), a quick look at the agenda of the event looks intriguing, even if these are largely about experts and agents involved with water resources talking to each other. For example, a "panel" that begins at 10, ends with a noon cut-off for "lunch." No question and answer session? Call me jaded after so many academic conferences where a small group is only addressing a small group (usually itself). We'll see -- participation is certainly not explicitly scheduled or listed so it'll be interesting if it's a repeat of the MRG Water Assembly I attended a few months ago, or some new beast. Pardon my skepticism. You can see the old topics from the MRG version along with some presentations here . But I hope it's a good meeting, since I'm not sure I'll have the stamina to attend the Buckman Diversion Project public meeting on water quality (= LANL connect...

Water, past and present

Image
As 2009 closes, I'm more than mid-way through this research stay in New Mexico focused on acequias and adjudication. A couple of recent posts from elsewhere caught my eye, one coming from Emily Green's excellent blog ( ChanceofRain ). This rather nostalgic, and halfway complete, post by a contributor on Spain's system of irrigation works and irrigation mentality was pretty interesting. As one critic noted, however, the post had it only partly right and I would also point to Glick's excellent work on water in Valencia for those wanting to track down the roots of Old World contributions to our New World variants. While the Romans had already put down an impressive hydraulic management template on the Iberian Peninsula, the Moors clearly added on, complemented existing features, and also introduced important institutional aspects of water management. It makes me want to track down the old norias (water wheels) once common in Spain and Portugal. Only a few in Mexico rema...