Posts

Showing posts with the label acequias

Real estate titles and acequias

Image
A recent post on the TVAA pages caught my eye, written by a real estate agent based in Espanola. It reads nicely, and it's meant for a wider audience looking to buy property. This is not an anti-property, anti-real estate screed, it's merely a reminder. One of the easiest ways to protect acequias as a ditch, institution, and their important easements is to spread the word about them prior to new property ownership. While I can appreciate this column for what it is, a kind of public-service announcement meets real estate moxy, how many people will stumble on this? Will the dude from Minnesota find this post or clipping from the paper? Wouldn't acequias in the region be better served if property title codes or statutes were changed to protect the ditch and institution? This way local knowledge could be incorporated into title deeds. Or at least it lays the groundwork for better neighborly interactions if a purchaser has a heads-up. I've mentioned this in passing to se...

Adjudication as "translating property"

Image
I had a great lunch yesterday with two well-placed people inside the Office of the State Engineer. Their interests are in law , and let us call them "Dick" and "Jane" for anonymity. And what I came away with, at least, was that adjudication is, in Maria Montoya’s language, a work of property translation . It is the state’s way of seeing and knowing what exists by way of water resources within its own boundaries. And before New Mexico can “ see like a state ” it has to “know” what is “out in” the state by way of rights to water. It’s a necessary (by law) first step to do priority administration in the state of New Mexico, under the doctrine of prior appropriation , even if “active management” of water is now allowed under state statute. We covered a number of aspects over the two hours of discussion: what the latest settlement agreements (passed in the U.S. House) may mean for tackling other, on-going adjudications; the limitations of staffing to actually field...

New Mexico, Bolivia, and customary water traditions

Image
A few days ago, I compared the interesting parallels (and differences) between New Mexico and the country of Spain. This time around, it's New Mexico and Bolivia ; here I want to create an opening for analyzing how both entities (again, a state, and a State respectively) have recognized local, customary water traditions. As you will see and appreciate, there are strong material parallels between how irrigators in Bolivia operate and how acequias in New Mexico handle water management and governance. The differences, however, are just as fascinating and have largely to do with how the claims to water are wrapped around cultural identity. My good colleague, Tom Perreault (Syracuse - Geography), wrote about the recent recognition in Bolivia of local "usos y costumbres" with special focus on the national irrigators' movement. Granted, that country has pursued an arguably anti-neoliberal path on water goverance in recent years, as Tom has suggested. But both Bolivia an...

A first pass at a research summary on acequias/adjudication

Image
This morning, I got the first shot at a public presentation, to an audience of ~16 people at the monthly meeting of the New Mexico Acequia Commission. I want to thank the out-going Chair of the NMAC, Ralph Vigil, for allowing me time to vent on this issue. It was simply, at this stage, a report on "what others have told me" about adjudication issues in/of acequias throughout the state. No disclaimer was needed, I hope, given the fact that it was so brief. There were some members of the OSE present, a few occasionally shaking heads, so it's clear that the story (like any) is only half-right at this stage. But it gave me the opportunity to see what works in the narrative, and what doesn't or needs serious improvement. I'm only doing a first-screen image insert here, since I cannot post the entire document until I'm satisfied that all errors are corrected.  Gracias!

Chamita, San Gabriel, and the ghosts of old capitals

Image
Yesterday I went out to Chamita , NM, for a visit with the Rundstroms. Ron and Pat have a third of an old long-lot with their own adobe house, and small guest-house for visitors. They're also fans of the old Spanish Aparejo packing system (donkey and mule-based), and had two live assistants on hand, Amiga and Freighter. It was a wide-ranging discussion, mostly focused on interactions with the OSE and how priority dates get established, fixed, and yes...negotiated. I met their mayordomo, Eloy Garcia, at the Congreso in Santa Fe the previous week , so this was a follow-up visit to learn more about the site, the town, and their on-going process of adjudication. Since even earnest lawyers and counsel believe in negotiation, mediation, it's no wonder that ditch dates would seem... flexible. For engineers hiring free-lance historians, it's also no wonder that all they want is a single date, a year, a month, a day (if possible). And for historians who consult for OSE on priority...

Climate politics, resilience, and stale appropriation

Image
As the world's leading politicians are meeting, hoping to hammer out some piddling gesture towards solving climate change (as a contruct) by reducing emissions, this is simply a brief "poke in the eye" at prior appropriation . Happy Thanksgiving New Mexico! That we have the "first in time, first in right" attitude towards water, and apparently not much else, is simply ludicrous. And if the Western States hope to really enforce future "calls on water" by senior water rights holders, they're dreaming at this point. Even in Colorado, the state engineer...excuse me, State Engineer, can issue a " futile call " (scroll down to 'f') if trying to enforce a senior right will result in no water. Remember 2002? You would if you were in Colorado or New Mexico at the time; depending on the data you consult or the model you believe in, it may have been the dryest year in 300+ years. It made the early 1950s drought look cuddly for these two s...

Acequias, meet your commission

Image
One of the most fascinating aspects about acequias in New Mexico is the apparent "division of labor" for these ditches and institutions. This morning, I attended the latest meeting of the New Mexico Acequia Commission , a body of representative appointed by the Governor of the state. It is currently chaired by Ralph Vigil, also an employee of the New Mexico Acequia Association . There's no accident here, as Ralph himself made clear, since the Commission (a government body) used to get its budget indirectly through the NMAA, as part of the latter's state funding specified carving out a chunk from its governance for the Acequia Commission's use. The NMAA is a non-profit, not a state agency. So, no wonder sometimes people are confused about who does what, in what capacity, and for whom. The main "action item" on the agenda for this morning would be predictable for most state employees in the current economy: budget cuts, and budget freezes . In this case,...

Thinking like a (State) Engineer

Image
Just returned from a long and fruitful discussion with New Mexico's State Engineer, John D'Antonio, and his OSE associate and Acequia Liaison, Hilario Rubio. It is always easier to write theoretically, and in diatribe mode, as a social scientist when state "officials" are depersonalized (as is common). Among the topics discussed: acequia responses to adjudication (multiple and regionally variable), Active Water Resource Management and its continuing legal and administrative challenges across the state, the Mimbres River, the Mora Valley, and areas that have been adjudicated (Red River, Mimbres), are in the process of being adjudicated (Pojoaque Valley, Taos Valley, Chama), or where adjudication has not even begun (Middle Rio Grande). They have my sympathy in trying to actively manage water resources in an arid state with essentially three operational sets of water law in place: federal and Pueblo reserve rights, Spanish and Mexican arrangements for water-sharing (...

How the West was Won (by some), Las Vegas-style

Image
I sat in on two court meetings, overseen by a Special Master for the Pecos River (adjudications) this morning, the first on the shortage-sharing agreements in the larger Las Vegas area, the second on the Pecos River adjudication itself. Sharing a "shortage" may seem like negative accounting to some, but it has a long and rich customary history in New Mexico. I will try not to be wordy, which is difficult when you have to explain concepts like "legal threshold" (great euphemism), but it was both a dull and interesting moment to observe. These proceedings can inherently be dull because it is a discussion, most of the time, about agreements already entered into, a kind of status check so that the Special Master can observe if on-going negotiations and settlements between parties (say, Las Vegas and the regional acequias) are having their desired effect, hopefully a long-term settlement. Part A of the proceedings this morning was really about the now remanded Pueblo...

Acequia hydrology, redux

Image
A brief report on the two-day "acequia hydrology" symposium here in Santa Fe at the fair grounds; Wednesday, October 21st was largely the PowerPoint and light discussion format for presenting the latest, or at least recent, findings from the New Mexico State University Alcalde research station. Steven Guldan and Sam Fernald, along with their current or former students Carlos Ochoa, Quita Ortiz and Ciara Cusack, gave the audience some quantitative data from hydrological and/or land-use research to go along with the qualitative data that parciantes, mayordomos and previous authors have provided for many years. These were quite interesting, less for their content personally because I've read these studies in article format already, for the reactions that were evoked in the audience. Clearly, some wanted these data as a kind of affirmation of what they "long known, always," others were interested in acquiring the data for legal cases still pending or under appeal...

Waiting for Aamodt, not Godot

Image
It's been a busy, and strange, week. A few conversations fell through, others materialized, and then topped off with the arrival of my book galley proofs (yuck). I was distracted enough to miss the editorial and subsequent editorials (x4) on the Aamodt settlement and what it will "do" for the Pojoaque residents, not to mention many Santa Fe residents with some dissenters obvious. Other news had it that Las Campanas has pulled the plug on its partner role in the Buckman project. No surprise there - benefits, yes please; obligations...uh, try us again later (just kidding, we're broke). My condolences to Rick. So this will be the first post of many, long overdue, as I enter what I'm officially calling "acequia week" since activities begin with the Acequia Hydrology Symposium and its associated field tour the next day; follow that up with some sexy proofing, a nice picnic on Sunday with friends, then a subcommittee on acequias (pdf) hearing and meeti...

on public scholarship...

Image
So it is back to water this week. A colleague and I have to write a public piece, for a newsletter circulating in northern New Mexico, about a recent decision to deny a water rights transfer (or "conveyance") along an acequia, and from an acequia to a dry promontory dividing two drainages, between Chupadero and Rio En Medio. Without too many details, the applicant is a famous land-owner in Santa Fe and has several local restaurants to his name. He also owns a small wine-shop, which I guess I should now boycott given what I know. His request to "move" water rights downstream, along an acequia, to a different tract of land wouldn't be so problematic if he acknowledged the governance and oversight of the local acequia association. But he wants no part of the acequia as a political institution he'd have to participate in, he just wants the water. Sorry buddy, but you live in New Mexico, and it's a package deal. His ludicrous request is to transfer surface wa...

Ombudspeople and outreach

Yesterday, I had the good fortune to chat with Darcy Bushnell who heads the Utton Ombudsman Program at the University of New Mexico. Specifically, she is tasked with outreach to folks dealing with water rights adjudications as executed by the Office of the State Engineer in New Mexico. Their office "does not provide legal advice," in Bushnell's words, but does offer some guidance on steps and what to anticipate next as part of the adjudication process . She related how some people react with such fear that they won't even open their mail from the State Engineer's office, worrying that it might be bad news. In the afternoon, I met with Denise Bleakly, a fellow geographer who works as a GIS resource specialist at one of the national labs in Albuquerque. Denise has been doing independent volunteer work up in Embudo and Dixon, helping parciantes map their acequias with GPS units and hopes to provide some basic outline and base maps for the community to use soon. I...

Acequias, hydrology, riparian habitat

Image
So I've signed up for the Acequia Hydrology symposium and field tour on October 21 & 22 to learn a bit more about the relationships between surface irrigation and natural stream channels, much of it gleaned from experimental research done at the NMSU Alcalde Field Station where the Rio Grande leaves its steep canyon and emerges into the relatively flatter area around Embudo and Alcalde. I have read much of the work by Guldan, Fernald, Ortiz , and many others working out of NMSU - it's refreshing to see this work see the light of day. It shows that "water resources" experts and civil engineers have a lot to contribute, and a lot to learn, towards the impacts and after-effects of surface irrigation technologies that aren't directed by 30" pipe. Listening to local knowledge makes sense for a lot of reasons, in this case. What will be of interest is how the socio-economic picture of acequias, and their current challenges given the difficult of small-scale ...

Rio Embudo Tales

Image
Yesterday I had the chance to speak to Estevan Arellano, a former journalist, a parciante on the Acequia Junta y Cienega, that uses the Rio Embudo close to its juncture (hence "junta") to the Rio Grande. For those who don't know him, Arellano is the editor and translator of "Ancient Agriculture" (originally published in 1513 in Spain) and has been active in acequia and community organization efforts for years. While parciantes on the AJyC are paying fairly high dues, it is a self-levied tax to keep the system operating, the banks cleared, and the amount of phreatophytes to a minimum to ensure some minimal flows for irrigation use. Only two folks out of 34 are 'delinquent' on their dues, one of whom is an absentee land-owner, and this provoked much discussion about the problems of the post-modern acequia. With retirees buying up former irrigated land at $50-100k/acre, they desire the aesthetic product of a managed landscape without the effort needed to a...

Romance, roots, and reality: Acequias sin parciantes?

Image
At an interesting set of mini-lectures last night, in Taos, UNM's Sylvia Rodriguez and Enrique Lamadrid were joined by journalist and agriculture-enthusiast Estevan Arellano, at the UNM-Taos campus just south of town, to discuss acequias in a new series on Agua y Cultura. If there was something of note, it's that the two academics seemed more hopeful, more in optimistic key, than the veteran parciante from Embudo (Arellano). Lamadrid discussed some of the recent summer trips to Mexico, where they went to rural Chihuahua, places like Aldama in the Allende Valley, to find the roots of New Mexican agricultural and irrigation practices. Sylvia, of course, emphasized the local dimension in Taos but did connect them to the autonomous irrigation communities that can be found in hundreds of places around the globe. Cue Arellano, who simply started reciting a few grim statistics from both acequia areas and the Pueblos themselves nearby, that few are planting anymore. Few parciantes are ...

Mujeres de agua y ley

A quick update - I had two productive meetings today in Albuqueruque. First, I met Melanie Stansbury , a Cornell grad student who is finishing up a doctoral dissertation on the Aamodt settlement; it sounds fascinating, and it also has an applied, conflict-resolution story to tell about why it took so long for the OSE, the Pueblos, and the "non-Pueblos" to finally get along in some sort of tentative draft settlement. Although not technically finalized, the state reps and senators are on to seeking funding for the 'federal solution' to Aamodt. Second, I met with author and anthropology Sylvia Rodriguez, who wrote one of the two seminal texts on acequias ( Acequia , SAR Press - Santa Fe - 2006). While slowly starting to re-pack and de-content her anthropology office, Sylvia is moving into the Alfonso Ortiz Center to guide future participatory action research projects through UNM and other interested parties in the local and regional community. I then had time to peruse...

Farmers, Markets, and contacts...on a Saturday

A quick visit to the S.Fe Farmer's Market this morning was hassled, busy, yet productive in the end. I was able to speak for a few minutes to Don Bustos, organic farmer extraordinaire, from Santa Cruz (Espanola area), about adjudications in his area. He noted that some of the local Pueblos were contesting the latest adjudications and maps and that this might compromise any quick close to the legal process in the area. These were apparently over "quarter acres, half acres, small bits of land" supposedly. Stay tuned... I also met for the first time, and was humbled by, Stanley Crawford of Dixon, NM. For the uninformed, Mr. Crawford's book, simply titled "Mayordomo," still stands as the best description of irrigation management on a small-scale in New Mexico. He was also hammered by a flock of produce shoppers, so we speak for maybe five minutes. Still, I look forward to visiting Crawford's "El Bosque" Garlic farm in Dixon. It should be a treat. ...

Geographers on the Rio Chupadero (sort of)

Image
Dave C and Eric P, debating trans-basin acequia diversions, here near the headwaters of the Rio en Medio, as part of it gets split (background) into the Rio Chupadero for irrigation. Photo courtesy of Eric Shultz.

Big water, small water

Image
So, after about three weeks of reading, discussions with 'water experts,' site visits, interviews, and driving around...it's clear to me that adjudication in New Mexico should have ignored acequias (and Pueblos!) entirely in terms of water rights. Their needs are so "small water" compared to the urban projects underway to deliver water ("big water") that trying to take poor Hispanic and Pueblo irrigators to court and make them 'prove up' their water rights is like trying to fumigate every apple in an orchard individually...silly. A quick visit out to the Buckman Project site confirmed these thoughts as I heard engineers, hydrologists, and a lawyer discuss their plans to siphon off Rio Grande waters from near the White Rock overlook area, and pump that water uphill to the suburbs and holding tanks west and southwest of Santa Fe. Oh, but it's not Rio Grande water, it's technically "San Juan and Chama Rivers" water that Santa Fe ...