Posts

Showing posts with the label Aamodt

Return of the blog, part 68

Image
This is a long-overdue quick post to get my blogging engine running again. I'm now back in New Mexico, on the outskirts of the captial, with a spectacular view from our casita of the Jemez Mountains and its current state of smoke and fire. In the first week of July, the scene was straight out of a Lord of the Rings set of Mordor ( photo ). I'm here to not only try to write several pieces on the larger water governance, adjudication, and acequias project but also to work with one of our Southwest Studies majors and a rising senior at Colorado College , Andrew Wallace. He has chosen to look at the Aamodt adjudication, now in settlement talks with all stakeholders, and how legal pluralism is or is not visible in the original case and the run-up to the settlement itself. Legal pluralism is a concept that originates from the critical legal studies literature, as well as from anthropologists like Laura Nader who made extensive use of it in her work, that speaks to whether multipl...

Post-settlement adjudications?

Image
This month's "acequias and adjudication" update will be old news for most of you who follow these issues closely, so apologies in advance. The point of this small post is to push through the seemingly finalized and maybe mundane details of an adjudication "settlement" and ask "what comes next?" The Aamodt ( Pojoaque Basin , NM) and the Abeyta (Taos Valley, NM) adjudications have been legally resolved through settlements funded, finally, by the U.S. Congress and the President's signature. This is good news for residents who worried about the long-term implications of these two pending lawsuits that embroiled locals, state officials, attorneys, the respective tribes, and finally, the federal agencies. Both of these lawsuits, shockingly, were older than I am, born in the late 1960s when water infrastructure and future projects pushed the state to finally file suit to document the water rights in the two water basins. You can easily find the detai...

Aamodt, Abeyta, Pojoaque Regional Water System

Image
First of all, apologies for the long interval and delay in this latest post. I had hoped to keep posting at a pace of about one comment per month, and administrative duties have taken their toll on this blog. But there's big news out from this past week, for all New Mexicans, even if the Aamodt-Abeyta settlements (for the Pojoaque Valley and Taos Valley, respectively) are supposed to be constrained to those water basins. The effects simply won't be. Funding for the settlement was approved on November 30th by the U.S. House of Representatives after already clearing the Senate, and it has money attached. The timing is tight, and frankly, lucky for those people who would fashion themselves as 'proponents' of the settlement. The legal team at the Office of the State Engineer must be relieved, if not overjoyed, that these old adjudications are seemingly put to rest. It puts to rest two of the longest running court processes in United States history, and will re-configure t...

Waiting for Aamodt, not Godot

Image
It's been a busy, and strange, week. A few conversations fell through, others materialized, and then topped off with the arrival of my book galley proofs (yuck). I was distracted enough to miss the editorial and subsequent editorials (x4) on the Aamodt settlement and what it will "do" for the Pojoaque residents, not to mention many Santa Fe residents with some dissenters obvious. Other news had it that Las Campanas has pulled the plug on its partner role in the Buckman project. No surprise there - benefits, yes please; obligations...uh, try us again later (just kidding, we're broke). My condolences to Rick. So this will be the first post of many, long overdue, as I enter what I'm officially calling "acequia week" since activities begin with the Acequia Hydrology Symposium and its associated field tour the next day; follow that up with some sexy proofing, a nice picnic on Sunday with friends, then a subcommittee on acequias (pdf) hearing and meeti...

Adjudication "stimulus package" and water-sharing in New Mexico

Image
The latest from D.C. is that the House and Senate bills on the Aamodt and Abeyta cases are moving through, and the final federal "stimulus package" amount will be hefty to quell these adjudication legacies in New Mexico. S. Matlock's piece in the New Mexican shows how determined certain parties are about pushing these funding bills through, given their longevity in the state's legal history. What is remarkable is how, especially in the Aamodt case, some of this negotiation went underground from the late 90s to when a settlement draft was proposed in 04. That these concerns about public access to information and what the settlement means (especially to "non-Pueblo" participants) are still problematic is really not all that surprising. One dimension that remains troubling, visible in a recent poll about Aamodt , is that people who claim to know something about the settlement are still unhappy about the terms. And even if the Taos area (Abeyta) settlement is...